Same recipe, different cheapest shop

Published October 12, 2026 · mitbringen · Savings & Prices

Same recipe, different cheapest shop: with almonds, a batch of Vanillekipferl is €0.29 cheaper at Billa than at Spar; with hazelnuts, Spar is €0.41 cheaper (as of 12.10.2026). mitbringen works out which shop wins for your list. And baked at home, a kilo costs only about €4.20 in ingredients, against €40 to €50 at a bakery, according to ORF.

Billa or Spar?

Same recipe, different cheapest shop: mitbringen compares your shopping list every week across Billa, Billa Plus, Spar, Hofer and Lidl and shows you where each ingredient is cheapest this week. Bring the savings home.

How we calculate it: one batch of Vanillekipferl

One batch of Vanillekipferl makes 676 g of dough and costs €2.83 in ingredients at Billa. We use the Dr. Oetker Vanillekipferl recipe: 280 g flour, 210 g butter, 100 g ground almonds, 70 g icing sugar and 2 sachets of vanilla sugar. Add 50 g icing sugar and 1 sachet of vanilla sugar for dusting. The recipe says it makes 70 to 80 Kipferl.

The formula: grams in the recipe × pack price ÷ pack size, for each ingredient, then add them up. We only count what you use, including the sugar for dusting. Electricity for the oven is not included.

Per kilo of dough that is €4.18 at Billa and €4.61 at Spar. Baking evaporates water from the butter, at most 16% of its weight. Even then, the finished kilo stays under €4.50 at Billa and under €5 at Spar.

Ingredients at Billa and Spar (own brand)

For this recipe Billa is 29 cents cheaper than Spar: €2.83 against €3.12 per batch.

Regular prices from the Billa and Spar online ranges, as of week 42/2026 (12.10.2026), no deals. Vanilla sugar: Clever 120 g €0.30, S-Budget 10 × 8 g €0.19, 6 cents in the recipe. Line items rounded, total calculated exactly. Hofer and Lidl are missing from this table because their regular prices are not fully available online. In the app, mitbringen includes their current offers in the comparison.

Flour and sugar cost the same at both. The difference is butter (9 cents) and almonds (20 cents). With hazelnuts it flips: 100 g cost €1.50 at Spar and €2.00 at Billa.

The cookie basket: Billa or Spar?

With almonds Billa wins by €0.29, with hazelnuts Spar wins by €0.41: your ingredient list decides, not the shop. Here is the same cookie basket in both versions.

Regular prices, as of 12.10.2026 (week 42/2026), no deals. Ground hazelnuts: BILLA 200 g €3.99, SPAR 200 g €2.99, 100 g in the recipe instead of the almonds. Hofer and Lidl are missing from this table because their regular prices are not fully available online. In the app, mitbringen includes their current offers in the comparison.

mitbringen runs this comparison for any shopping list, every week, at Billa, Billa Plus, Spar, Hofer and Lidl.

Put the ingredients on your list – mitbringen shows where each one is cheapest this week.

Butter and nuts make the price

Butter and almonds are 82% of the ingredient cost, while flour and sugar together are only 44 cents. If you want to save, look at those two shelves.

For nuts, the price per kilo helps. At Spar, ground hazelnuts cost €2.99 for 200 g, which is €14.95 per kilo. The 400 g pack costs €4.99, which is €12.48 per kilo. Baking four batches takes 400 g of nuts: one big pack then costs 99 cents less than two small ones. Deals come and go; the price per kilo is the measure.

Own brand instead of brand: €1.89 per batch

Swapping branded butter, sugar and almonds for own brands saves €1.89 per batch at Billa, about €2.80 per kilo of dough. Search the ingredient in mitbringen and brand and own brand show up side by side with prices.

Regular prices at Billa, Goldpack price from Spar, as of week 42/2026 (12.10.2026). Line items rounded, total calculated exactly.

Almonds and butter bring almost the whole saving. How this works across your whole shop: why own brands at Billa and Spar are the biggest lever.

Why bought cookies are so expensive

At a bakery a kilo of Christmas cookies costs €40 to €50, sometimes more, according to ORF Upper Austria (December 2025). Baked at home, it is €4.18 per kilo of dough in ingredients. Mostly you pay for the work: "It's 30 to 40 hand movements per cookie," a baker told ORF.

The ingredients got more expensive too. According to the Momentum Institut, cookie ingredients rose 33.4% in four years, against 28.5% for food overall. Sugar rose the most, by 45.3%. Butter is the exception: 250 g cost €2.79 at the cheapest seller in 2024 and €1.59 in December 2025. Clever butter at Billa also costs €1.59 on 12.10.2026.

Frequently asked questions

How much does a kilo of homemade Vanillekipferl cost?

About €4.20 in ingredients with Billa own brands (as of 12.10.2026). At Spar it is about €4.60. Calculated with the Dr. Oetker recipe for 70 to 80 Kipferl, per kilo of dough, without oven electricity.

Why are bought Christmas cookies so expensive?

Mostly because of the work. A baker told ORF in December 2025 that each cookie takes 30 to 40 hand movements. That is why a kilo costs €40 to €50 at a bakery, sometimes more.

Which ingredient makes cookies most expensive?

Butter and nuts. In the Vanillekipferl recipe, butter and almonds are 82% of the ingredient cost. Flour and sugar together cost only 44 cents per batch.

Is Billa or Spar cheaper for baking ingredients?

It depends on the recipe. On 12.10.2026 flour and icing sugar cost the same at both. Butter and almonds were cheaper at Billa, hazelnuts at Spar. With almonds the batch was 29 cents cheaper at Billa; with hazelnuts it was 41 cents cheaper at Spar.

Put your cookie basket on your list – mitbringen shows you where each ingredient is cheapest this week. Bring the savings home →

Illustrations: AI-generated

Keep reading